I started the draft for this post before reading Steven Landsburg’s The Big Questions. Only now, as I get back to completing it do I realize that he provided the perfect words to back up this point, and I’ve already posted those words.
The fact that “we (I certainly didn’t have anything to do with it) sent a man to the moon” has been used in many debates over what the government is capable of achieving. Maybe you’ve heard it. It usually goes something like this:
“If we can send a man to the moon, then we can…
…make sure everyone has health care
…ensure everyone has a good standard of living
…give everyone a vacation?” (This one surfaced recently in the UK. While they didn’t send a man to the moon, this shows where this logic can lead.)
Sending men to the moon was hard, no doubt.
But, the fallacy is generalizing what it takes to send a man to the moon is similar to what it takes to end poverty or give everyone health care.