The Performance Appraisal Myth

Each year, HR departments do their duty and administer the performance appraisal process.  Most folks seem to detest it.

There are good reasons for that.

If you work for company that does not do a good job of training and developing its people*, the performance appraisal process functions about as effectively as a New Years resolution treadmill.  It doesn’t.  It collects dust for a year, then there’s a flurry of activity for a short period and it’s forgotten again for another year.

If you work for a company or boss that does a good job of training and developing  people**, then the performance appraisal process is superfluous.  Good performance feedback occurs regularly.  These are like the fitness people who don’t need a New Years resolution to encourage them to stay in shape.  They have established the behavior and priority to exercise and these companies maintain the the behavior and priority for associate development. So, performance appraisal process becomes one of housekeeping and documentation.

Here’s how to tell which type of company you work for:

*In good economies, other companies tend not to recruit heavily from these companies and the folks who do leave, usually do so out of frustration.

**In good times, other companies actively recruit from your workforce and there’s usually a good number of people who leave through these opportunities, which opens doors for others to advance and replace them.

So, make a point in your next interview to ask your potential new boss whether the company’s talent is recruited away or if they leave on their own accord.  That can tell you a lot about what you may be getting into.