In a conversation this evening, I mentioned that one motivation for this blog was to combat fallacy. My counterpart said that I was the first person, besides himself, in years he has heard use that word.
That caused other conversations where I pointed out fallacies to flash through my mind. I often receive bewildered looks when I say that word. I assumed the looks reflected disagreement. But, maybe they simply didn’t know what I meant and they didn’t want to ask.
I admit, before I became familiar with the term I would not have known. I think the non-intuitive nature of the meaning of fallacy may be on par with economic rent. Neither term is used enough in everyday language to have gained an intuitive understanding.
For example, most people intuitively know that profits can be made in capitalism. They do not intuitively know that profits can also be made from economic rent. Economic rent is such a blind spot, in fact, that most folks commonly mistake profits from economic rent as profits from capitalism.
They also mistake fallacy for legitimate argument.
So, what is a fallacy?
A fallacy is faulty reasoning where the conclusion doesn’t follow from the premises given. A fallacy doesn’t necessarily say the conclusion is wrong, just that the conclusion can’t be made from the premises given.
Here’s an example of a fallacy:
It rained here today, so it will not rain tomorrow.
My premise is that it rained today. My conclusion, based on that premise, is that it will not rain tomorrow. But, rain today usually has no bearing on whether it will rain tomorrow.
Notice, my conclusion may be correct. It may not rain tomorrow. But most people will agree that the logic I used to arrive at my conclusion is not correct.
Fallacies come in many varieties. There are common fallacies that you have probably heard of like ad hominem attacks or red herrings and many more.
Over the years, I have found the list of informal fallacies at the Nizkor Project website to be a handy and valuable resource for checking and re-checking to help me identify fallacy.
Being able to spot and identify fallacies is like the Jujitsu of discussion allowing you to make progress without having to state and defend a case of your own. Simply pointing out incorrect reasoning turns the argument back on your discussion partner and causes them to rethink their logic.
Most important, it often focuses the discussion on the root cause of the disagreement — the faulty reasoning on which the conclusions are based.