…and a big problem with soccer in the U.S. is that there are many ways to win without being any good.
That’s true from top to bottom.
The MLS limits the number of good players on a team to even out the competition. It thinks close games attracts more fans.
Youth are separated into age and like skill groups where they can feel successful. The thinking is that winning keeps more kids interested longer.
The downside is that too many people win without being any good. That doesn’t help them get better because it isn’t clear that they need to get better.
Imagine watching a basketball game where players dribble the ball high and away from their body and turn the ball over frequently. Most of the passes they make get intercepted, and they can’t catch a pass. Players with the ball dribble past them easily.
This is what soccer in the U.S. looks like to me: too many players don’t even have the basics. I think a reason is that there’s a lot of winning and incentive to learn the basics.
The point of sports should be to win. But, it should be about winning by being good, not by watering down the competition.
One small example of this is juggling. Players and coaches alike have pleaded their case to me that practicing juggling is unnecessary. “It’s just for show,” they say, because you don’t use it in a game. “Work on the stuff that you actually use,” they say.
It is true that you don’t need to practice juggling, if you only play against others who also don’t know how to juggle.
But, when a juggler and non-juggler go into a 1v1 or 50/50, I’ll put my money on the juggler coming away with the ball.