Open Immigration

I think the biggest problem with immigration is that government limits it.

Good legislation mirrors social norms and the social norms recognize that most illegal immigrants are hard-working people looking for opportunity through value-added work effort rather than value-draining government benefit programs. That’s win-win. We should eliminate government limits on immigration to match what we believe to be true that we generally accept immigrants.

Now, some folks make the case that immigrants attracted by government handouts are a drain on society. However, I think that should be taken as a valid case against government handouts rather than immigration.

Others worry about the cultural impact of open immigration, yet the U.S. has survived many waves of immigrants before. I’m not sure I understand why a current wave should be feared, especially if they are coming here for opportunity.

Update: Here’s a good, related post on Arnold Kling’s askblog. In response to the analogy “Illegal immigrants are to immigration what shoplifters are to shopping,” Kling wrote:

Let me continue with the analogy. We have a store that makes the process of dealing with the sales clerks very complicated, with people having to stand in line at the cash register for years. Maybe we would not have so much shoplifting if we fixed the checkout process–or at least if we offered an “express lane” to people willing to pay a fee of $5,000 or so.

One of Kling’s commenters took it a bit further and wrote:

Illegal immigrants are to immigration what front-of-the-bus riders are to Jim Crow.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Open Immigration

  1. “I think (the case that immigrants attracted by government handouts are a drain on society) should be taken as a valid case against government handouts rather than immigration.”

    Our nation was founded by immigrants and, for almost two centuries, immigrants as a “drain” on our resources was nary a concern. The worry that cheap immigrant labor would “steal” American’s jobs was present, but the desire by the non-competitive class to eliminate the competition through rent seeking is easily understood – even if we don’t agree with it. I’m willing to bet that our own home grown moochers are a exponentially greater drain on our society in terms of grabbing for government handouts than are the foreign born moochers.

    • Great comment. I agree. Also, our home grown moochers could learn a thing or two from hard-working immigrants — legal and illegal.

Comments

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s